Johnny Rebb - Ain’t I’m A Dog (1963)

Ronnie Self - Ain’t I’m A Dog (1957)

(Wayne P. Walker - George Sherry [Troy Lee Martin])
 USA
Original version
#31 Sydney | #21 Australia*

Single on Columbia in USA, on Coronet in Australia. Also released by Columbia on 78 rpm disc. 

Ronnie Self (1938-1981) was a talented rock-rockabilly-pop performer who recorded many singles but never saw chart success in the US. He had two Top 40 singles in Sydney, Australia in 1958 with Ain’t I’m A Dog (#31 Sydney, #21 Australia*) and Bop-A-Lena (#25 Sydney, #63 USA), and he is still highly regarded by rockabilly fans, especially in Europe.

He is also remembered for his songwriting, especially for Brenda Lee’s breakthrough hits Sweet Nothin’s (1960, #4 USA) and I’m Sorry (1960, #1), then for Everybody Loves Me But You (1962, #6).

A co-writer credit to Self’s (and Brenda Lee’s) manager Dub Allbritten appears on Sweet Nothin’s and I’m Sorry, as well as on the lesser hits Eventually (1961, #56) and Anybody But Me (1961 #31). This seems to have been a financial arrangement rather than a collaboration.

Dub wasn’t a songwriter, but his name is listed as the co-writer on a lot
of Ronnie’s songs. I don’t think he was trying to be dishonest.That was
the only way Dub could hope to recoup all the money he’d invested in
that crazy guy.

Brenda Lee in her autobiography Little Miss Dynamite (2002) p.64

Jake Hess’s recording of a Ronnie Self composition, Ain’t That Beautiful Singing (1969), won the Grammy Award for Best Sacred Performance (Non-Classical).

Why Ronnie Self never made it as a performer is one of the great mysteries and injustices of pop music history… He should have been there, thought of in the same breath as [Carl] Perkins or Jerry Lee Lewis; instead, he’s a footnote in rock & roll history outside of Europe, where he’s treated as a legend.
           – Bruce Eder, All Music

---

The writing credits
1. Wayne Paul Walker (1925-1979) recorded as a country-rockabilly singer on a number of labels from the mid-50s, but his greatest success was as a songwriter, mainly in country music. He started recording and writing when he was appearing on Louisiana Hayride on KWKH Shreveport. In 1954, his first record came out on Chess, and he co-wrote How Do You Think I Feel (with Webb Pierce), recorded by country star Red Sovine (1954) and by Elvis Presley on Elvis (1956). By 1956 Walker was living in Nashville, signed as a writer for Cedarwood publishers, and recording for Columbia, Coral and Brunswick.

Some notable Wayne Walker compositions from a large repertoire include:
• Are You Sincere (Andy Williams, 1958 #3 USA; Elvis Presley 1973 on Raised On Rock);
• Cut Across Shorty (Eddie Cochran 1960; Rod Stewart 1970 on Gasoline Alley, co-wr. Marijohn Wilkin;
• Little Boy Sad (Johnny Burnette 1961, #17 USA; MPD Ltd 1965).

2. George Sherry is a pseudonym of Troy Lee Martin (1911-1977) a Nashville music publisher, talent scout and producer who in the 30s had been a singer, comedian, and wild west show manager. His writer credits, which appeared on many works he published or produced, used several aliases including George Sherry, Jerry Organ, and Shirley Lynn, as well as variations of his real name.

The All Music biography (my main source), noting that Martin’s involvement in country music has never been properly recorded, traces various roles in several companies from the post-war 1940s to the early 70s. It mentions numerous songs that he brought to prominence, and concludes that he had the undoubted ability to select a hit song.

---

Ain’t I’m a dog?
The wording of the title Ain’t I’m A Dog can be baffling, and I’ve seen examples where chart compilers have tried to correct it, to Ain’t I A Dog or (less convincingly) Ain’t Me A Dog.

I’d assumed it was unique to this song, but in fact the construction isn’t unheard of in American English. It has been discussed at length at the linguistics forum Language Log, where other examples are given, such as “Ain’t this is a great country…”

In a post headed “Ain’t I’m a Stinkah”, Eric Bakovic writes that  Ain’t I’m a Dog  [makes] perfect sense if you take ‘ain’t’ to be a phrase-initial marker meaning something like “isn’t it the case (that)”, “don’t you agree (that)”, “it’s clear (that)”, or the like — observe: “It’s clear that I’m a dog; I’m always steppin’ around.“

I don’t pretend to understand all of that, let alone the whole discussion thread, but you can follow it up here if you’re game.  Links back to previous posts are included there.

---

* Charts: I’m no statistician but the chart positions #31 Sydney (The Book and Gavin Ryan) and #21 Australia (Top 100 Singles using AMR) look like an anomaly, but they are all I have.

References, further reading: 1. Ronnie Self story at This Is My Story which led me to the Brenda Lee quote. 2. Ronnie Self: Biography by Bruce Eder at All Music. 3. Ronnie Self by Dave Stephens at Toppermost. 4.  Ronnie Self – Bop-A-Lena at Michael Jack Kirby’s Way Back Attack. 5. Wayne Walker page at This Is My Life. 6. Wayne Walker discography at 45cat.com. 7. Wayne Walker: selected discography with audio samples and label shots at Rockin’ Country Style. 8. Troy Martin aka Troy Lee Martin: Biography (uncredited) at All Music. 9. Troy Martin at Discogs.com. 10. Eric Bakovic, Ain’t I’m A Stinkah, post at Language Log, 2004 (scroll down).