Thanks to David Johnston for suggestion.
Single on Columbia (SA) by South African group that later had an international hit with Master Jack (1968, #18 USA). Timothy charted in NZ in 1968, after Master Jack.
This version of Timothy was the #12 South African hit for 1967.
Single on Columbia (SA) by Netherlands-born South African singer and pioneering SA children's TV presenter Carike Keuzencamp (b.1947). She sings Timothy in the 1968 film Professor en die prikkelpop (The Professor and the Beauty Queen), written and directed by Jamie Uys, later famous for The Gods Must Be Crazy (1980).
This version of Timothy was the #14 South African hit for 1967.
The writer, full name Jacobus Cornelius Erasmus, is familiarly known as 'Dopper' Erasmus.
Further reading: Carike Keuzencamp at Discogs.com.
Single on RCA. Country singer Skeeter Davis (1931-2004) also found success on the pop charts, notably with The End Of The World (1963, #2 USA) and the Goffin-King composition I Can’t Stay Mad At You (1963, #7 USA).
Further reading: Skeeter Davis biography at All Music.
SAME TITLE BUT NOT THE SAME SONG AS
'TIMOTHY' BY ANNE HAWKER.
As a solo artist, composer Rupert Holmes later had hits with Escape (The Pina Colada Song) (1979, #1 USA) and Him (1980, #6 USA). His skills include arranging and producing, and writing Broadway productions.
It's a classic death pop number, the sprightly tale of three miners trapped by a cave-in who turn to cannibalism for survival during their ordeal. Despite the
gruesome theme, "Timothy" has a hooky chorus and a production rich with brass and strings…
– Fred Beldin, album review at All Music.
Thanks to Tim Campbell for red herring alert.